Talk:Kirlin

So, it looks like this article should probably be deleted. --- Slarty 22:20, 26 March 2006 (CST)

Blanking for now. Arancaytar | Send Reply! --- That is not dead which can eternal lie... 03:53, 28 March 2006 (CST)

In or out, can't have both.

Either we delete this entirely and keep it out, or we put the blanked content back in - makes no sense to rewrite from scratch since the original content was thrown out on principle, not quality.

(Personally, I have no problem with what is reasonably good content, especially now the apocrypha tags are everywhere anyway. But I'd rather have this decided instead of simply filling this page again.) -- Arancaytar | Send Reply! --- That is not dead which can eternal lie... 02:49, 16 July 2007 (PDT)

I can't remember anymore why I made the comment above: either it was during the brief period that I was following our old policy on excluding noncanon material, or it was because Drakey somehow convinced me about the geographical conflict with community canon. I don't remember the latter ever happening, but it's possible. The conflict was that Drakey et al's maps of Valorim have water where Kirlin claims to be. Jeff's Valorim maps end at the northern mountains and it does not state anywhere in the games that there's water on the other side, so given the quality of Kirlin's source scenarios, we can probably keep it. I'll put the old material back in. -- Slarty 07:37, 16 July 2007 (PDT)

Some of this stuff was discussed over at the forum, which I locked down due to the spam. I'll see if I can make the forum available again as an archive so we can read all this. It wasn't much, but we did have a few important policy discussions there. -- Arancaytar | Send Reply! --- That is not dead which can eternal lie... 23:22, 16 July 2007 (PDT)